Apkarian, Jacob. 2027. “Contradictory Logics and the Maintenance of Professional Subdomains: A Lesson from the Financial Security Analysis Industry.” Journal of Professions and Organization 14(1):joaf010. https://doi.org/10.1093/jpo/joaf010.
Abstract: The division of professions into professional subdomains has been underexplored in the professions literature. Drawing on the financial security analysis industry as an example, I introduce a theoretical model outlining the processes that reinforce intra-professional jurisdictions in the industry. Specifically, I argue that competing demands from clients can generate contradictory logics within a professional industry, which are utilized to legitimate and sustain professional subdomains. These subdomains, comprised of similarly trained professionals with similar expertise, often housed within the same organization, draw on different logics to guide the professional production process. This allows them to produce distinct sets of products and services to meet the contradictory demands of their clients. An analysis of firm financial data indicates that, despite the fact that each subdomain promotes contradictory corporate behaviors as valid and rational, they may be economically justified in doing so, thereby legitimating their continued jurisdictions within the industry. While organizational scholars have identified a variety of approaches utilized by professionals to reconcile conflicting logics, I propose that one process in particular—compartmentalization—has implications for jurisdiction and the maintenance of professional subdomains. This research unites leading theories of institutional logics with theories of professions to present a novel model of how professional subdomains can successfully coexist within a professional industry by legitimating their jurisdictional claims via contradictory logics. It also offers a contribution to economic sociology by formalizing characteristics of the market logics of equity and debt investment, which have been demonstrated to jointly influence corporate decision-making.
Author: Jacob Apkarian is an Associate Professor of Sociology at York College, City University of New York (CUNY), and a Research Fellow at the National Center for the Study of Collective Bargaining in Higher Education and the Professions at Hunter College. His research examines organizational governance and the institutional logics guiding organizational decision-making in the finance industry and higher education.